The Dreaded "PFIC" Rules: How to Limit the Damage

Image courtesy iStock.

Image courtesy iStock.

In a world that is becoming smaller, money-making opportunities present themselves all over the globe.  However, with said opportunity comes the obligation to pay taxes.  Otherwise prudent investors can find themselves in a precarious tax situation when they discover that they have been investing in what the U.S. tax rules refer to as “PFICs,” or Passive Foreign Investment Companies.  PFIC investments come with a unique set of compliance rules, and failure to meet these requirements can come with a hefty tax bill and/or penalties.


There are two tests to determine if a foreign corporation falls into the PFIC category:

  • The Income Test: 75% or more of the corporation’s gross income for the taxable year is passive income. Passive income includes, but is not limited to, dividends, interest, royalties, rents, and annuities
  • The Assets Test: 50% or more of the corporation’s total assets are passive assets (based on average market value, or adjusted basis if qualified and elected)


So you determine that the foreign corporation is subject to PFIC rules.  There are three main ways the U.S. Government can tax a PFIC investment:

  • “Excess Distributions” Regime
  • Qualifying Elected Fund “QEF” Election
  • “Mark-to-Market” Election

By default, a PFIC will fall under the excess distribution method.  Tax recognition under this regime is not triggered by income earned but rather by distributions received. An excess distribution is a distribution that is greater than the base amount, defined as 125% of the average actual distributions received from the three prior years (or less, if owned for less time).  Once the base amount is determined, any part of the current year distribution that is above the base amount is considered excess.  The base amount is taxed as ordinary dividends, but the excess distribution is allocated to the entire holding period and taxed at the highest tax bracket for each year, thereby eliminating the deferral of yearly tax amounts.  There is also an interest charge associated with the excess distribution, calculated at the underpayment rate, which is the AFR short term rate plus 3%.  This would be considered a penalty regime, since you have been deferring foreign income from the U.S. Government, and as such they charge you interest to make up for it.  This default method is complex and cumbersome, to say the least.


Generally, the reporting for a PFIC is the responsibility of the first U.S. taxpayer owning the investment.  If this is the first year owning the PFIC, you can (and should – depending on your tax situation) make the QEF election to report all income currently.  A QEF election will treat the investment in the manner similar to that of a domestic mutual fund.  Your pro rata share of interest and dividends will be taxed at ordinary income tax rates and capital gains at the capital gains rate, even if you did not receive any distributions for the year.  Any distributions that you receive subsequently from the previously taxed income would be received tax free to you.  Important: a QEF election can generally only be made in the first year owning the investment.  There are retroactive elections and ways to “purge the PFIC taint,” thereby regaining the ability to make a QEF election, but those concepts are outside of the scope of this blog.  You should, however, be aware that they are available as a potential tax strategy.

If the QEF election cannot be made, another possibility to limit the damage would be the “Mark-to-Market” election.  This election was created to extend the current year income treatment that the QEF election offers for those investors that were unable to elect QEF.  If the PFIC stock is marketable (that’s an important qualification), you can elect to pick up the excess in fair market value over adjusted basis of the stock as ordinary income in the taxable year.  Your basis in the stock adjusts  accordingly in the year the income is recognized.  If there is a decrease in fair market value, losses can be taken to the extent of prior “unreversed inclusions”.  Prior unreversed inclusions are prior year mark-to-market gains that were previously picked up as income.  Any losses above and beyond the unreversed inclusions are lost.

The PFIC rules are extremely complicated, and we’ve only scratched the surface of navigating potential compliance issues.  If you think that you may have investments subject to the PFIC rules, you should reach out to a trusted professional to discuss your options.